
The dam may have burst on Sandpapergate. Cameron Bancroft has broken eight years of silence, claiming the whole team knew about the sandpaper in Cape Town, and Pat Cummins’ position as Australia captain is now in the spotlight. Former players, broadcasters and fans have wasted no time weighing in.
Bancroft, the former Test opener banned over the 2018 Cape Town incident, set out his account in a column for The West Australian. He wrote that the entire team knew he was using sandpaper on the ball during the South Africa tour.
He said the bowlers gave him feedback on his work, and that a coach told him to do more. His column landed only days after Usman Khawaja made similar claims in his autobiography, Sabr.
Bancroft said Cummins’ lengthy press conference rejecting those claims left him feeling angry, betrayed and alone. That, he said, was the trigger for his own account.
Bancroft backed Khawaja’s claim that then bowling coach David Saker approached him during the second innings in Cape Town and said he had to do more. He also described regular conversations with the fast bowlers about whether the ball was reverse swinging enough.
“I wanted and needed feedback. How else am I to know if what I’m doing is effective or not if I don’t have these conversations with the bowlers bowling with it and the wicketkeeper?” he wrote.
He added that Steve Smith made it clear he wanted no part in it before distancing himself from the conversation.
Cummins addressed the media to give his version of events. He was firm on what he knew, and what he did not.
“When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, that is 100% wrong,” Cummins said. He added that he has said the same thing consistently for eight years.
He also said he was surprised to learn Khawaja had admitted telling Bancroft to be careful when using sandpaper. The suggestion that he and others were architects of a tampering scheme, he said, was “complete and utter nonsense”.
Cummins rejected the idea that the team had moved from legal methods of getting the ball to reverse to a deliberate, organised use of illegal ones. He said that context had not been told enough.
“There’s no grand plan. There’s no team meeting. There’s no bowlers saying this is what must happen. I think there are natural progressions that get you there,” he said.
The gap between the two versions is stark. Here is how the key points compare.
| Issue | Bancroft’s Account | Cummins’ Response |
|---|---|---|
| Team knowledge | The entire team knew about the sandpaper | Says it is “100% wrong” that the group knew |
| Bowler feedback | Bowlers told him whether his work on the ball was effective | Bowlers have consistently denied knowledge of tampering |
| Planning | Coach told him to do more in Cape Town | “No grand plan” and no team meeting |
The first big reaction came from British broadcaster Piers Morgan, who took aim at the captain on X. “Wow… the dam bursts,” he wrote, before asking how Cummins could survive and stay Australia’s captain.
Former South Africa fast bowler Dale Steyn, who was on the opposing side in Cape Town, posted that the affair “ain’t ever going away” for the Australians.
Former Australian batter Damien Martyn echoed the phrase Bancroft and Khawaja have used, writing: “Agree…We all knew.” One fan account greeted Bancroft’s comments on Smith with a single word: “VINDICATION!”
Some users went further and demanded that Cummins resign. Those calls came quickly, long before anyone has established the full facts.
Social media is quick to turn a dispute into a verdict. Even so, Cummins has a real problem. He gave a long, detailed rejection, and a former teammate has now challenged it with specifics.
When two public accounts conflict this sharply, audiences rarely wait for a tidy resolution. The person who spoke first has the most to lose if the details change.
Cummins’ record as a leader is considerable, and a few posts should not decide his future. Still, trust is the currency of captaincy, and he will need his version to withstand scrutiny.
Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg has announced an independent forum for everyone who was on the 2018 South Africa tour. Players and staff will get a chance to speak.
If the key players take part, a clearer picture may emerge. It could support Cummins or leave him exposed. If the key voices stay away, the argument will carry on indefinitely.






