
David Warner has reignited the Sandpapergate storm, accusing Cricket Australia of running a flawed 2018 investigation. The former opener claims Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon were never interviewed, and says the process “stinks of a cover up”. Eight years on, the row is far from finished.
Warner released a new statement on Saturday, and this time his target was the governing body rather than the captain. He wrote that, as far as he is aware, CA did not interview Hazlewood, Starc or Lyon during its 2018 investigation.
The three bowlers played in the third Test against South Africa in Cape Town, alongside Pat Cummins. That was the match in which Cameron Bancroft was spotted handling sandpaper on the field.
Warner then questioned the logic of the board’s position. If the bowlers were never questioned, he asked, how can CA push the idea that they didn’t know?
“It looks like they had decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning, ran a shoddy investigation to serve the purpose and now they want to maintain the false narrative that the bowlers had no idea. That stinks of a cover up.”
The saga returned to the headlines after Usman Khawaja made explosive claims that the entire Australian team knew about the plan to tamper with the ball. Warner, who has also retired from international cricket, backed those claims straight away.
Cummins responded with a 70-minute press conference on Friday morning. He denied any prior knowledge and described the accusations as “complete nonsense” and “probably defamatory”.
By Friday afternoon, Warner had replied, saying Cummins had thrown Khawaja under the bus. He also described the original CA investigation as “botched”.
A day later, he released a written statement questioning who the investigators had actually spoken to. Saturday’s statement took that line of attack further.
| Day | Key Development |
|---|---|
| Friday morning | Cummins denies prior knowledge in a 70-minute press conference |
| Friday afternoon | Warner says Cummins threw Khawaja under the bus and calls the probe “botched” |
| Saturday | Warner claims Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon were not interviewed |
CA has not backed down. A spokesperson said all players were given the opportunity to speak at the time of the initial investigation.
“All players were given the opportunity to speak at the time of the initial investigation. They have had the ability to come forward with new evidence in the eight years since.”
The spokesperson added that CA has respected every player’s and former player’s right to provide their own version of events. Chief executive Todd Greenberg has already ruled out a new investigation.
Warner’s argument rests on one simple point. If the bowlers were never interviewed, the claim that they knew nothing rests on an absence of evidence rather than on anything they actually said.
That does not prove Warner right, and he was careful to say he was speaking “as far as I am aware”. CA’s counter is also fair: why did nobody come forward with new information in eight years?
Warner argued that the original inquiry left him, Steve Smith and Bancroft to carry the full weight of the blame. He said some of the questions felt as if the blame was being planted on them.
“Some of the questions were quite challenging in a way that it was being planted on us and we had to move on and accept responsibility, the three for us. And ultimately we did.”
He also noted that the trio no longer have a chance to put their side across again, because Greenberg has closed that door. Even so, Warner hinted that the story may continue away from the cameras.
“There’s probably going to be more conversations behind the scenes after this.”
Greenberg’s refusal to reopen the matter is understandable, since a fresh inquiry could drag on for months. But it also leaves questions hanging, and in sport, unanswered questions tend to grow louder with time.
With Warner, Khawaja and Cummins all now on record, Cricket Australia faces continued pressure to explain the gaps. Unless it does, this row looks set to keep returning.






